Opinion

The 2023 review of Pilot Transfer Arrangement Regulations, a chance for innovation?


by Herman Broers - published on 2 January 2023 454 -

Article and picture by Herman Broers, unlimited license Maritime Pilot, Port of Rotterdam, Netherlands.
Author of www.pilotladdersafety.com


In the spring of 2023, the IMO Sub-commission on Navigation, Communications and Search and Rescue (NCSR) may start a process of review and amendments to the SOLAS Ch V. reg 23: the regulations regarding Pilot Transfer Arrangements (PTAs).

The pilot ladder in use today dates back decades, if not centuries. When considering ISO standard 799-1 for instance, the design of the pilot ladder in use on most sea going vessels consists of materials and techniques that have been around for a long time.

Furthermore, after decades of defined regulations, guidelines, operational procedures, and standards, one could ask the question whether all these measures have led to substantial improvements for pilot ladders today and guarantee a safe boarding arrangement for the transfer of maritime pilots. The results of many hazardous occasions- and accident investigation studies indicate this is not the case.

When making alterations to PTA regulations in 2023, are we going to go more into the details of the present components in use, or are we going to consider a more holistic view of the PTA-system and start by defining risk-based safety requirements for a new future proof PTA system, using modern techniques, components, materials, and a human centered design approach?

Consider the following task: if we were to start from scratch, how would the ideal PTA look like? Using a Design Thinking approach, after identifying the design needs (i.e., defining the problems), PTA-stakeholders and known information on the present-day PTA system, the functional and operational applications and requirements should be defined to begin with.

Some obvious requirements of a safe PTA-system that come to mind: the new 2023 PTA system should have a high degree of safety, maintainability, and operability. The components and materials in use for the PTA system should be resistant to the harsh environment of the high seas. It should be easy to recognize wear and tear of the system during the life cycle, and training in the safe operations of the PTA system should be simple. The rigging of the system and the securing techniques should be straight forward and unambiguous.

Based on these requirements, a new PTA system can be designed in which innovation is given maximum priority. An associated requirements package of classification regulations should be established to enable testing- and verification procedures in line with the specified requirements. All stakeholders (e.g., maritime pilots, shipowners, legislators) should be involved in developing these procedures to come to the maximum support for the PTA system of the future. Any design that meets the established requirements should be certified when it is interesting enough to bring onto the global market.

In conclusion, it is time for a new “PTA as a system” approach, not for an upgrade of the existing pilot ladder. The efforts of the maritime industry should be aimed at improving maritime pilot safety using modern design and manufacturing techniques. The present PTA regulations, guidelines, procedures, and standards are an obstacle to innovation in this respect.

Herman Broers
Editor's note:
Opinion pieces reflect the personal opinion of individual authors. They do not allow any conclusions to be drawn about a prevailing opinion in the respective editorial department. Opinion pieces might be deliberately formulated in a pronounced or even explicit tone and may contain biased arguments. They might be intended to polarise and stimulate discussion. In this, they deliberately differ from the factual articles you typically find on this platform, written to present facts and opinions in as balanced a manner as possible.
Unlimited License Maritime Pilot, Port of Rotterdam. Pilot ladder safety, active marine pilot - Loodswezen Rotterdam - Rijnmond


Maritime Pilot in port of Rotterdam, Author of www.pilotladdersafety.com
What's your opinion on this?
Login or register to write comments and join the discussion!
Read more...

Video Kittiwake Mersey Pilot

published on 22 December 2021

KITTIWAKE ( MMSI 232008570) is a Pilot and currently sailing under the flag of United Kingdom (UK) Here she is speeding down the River this morning.

0

Video Polaris Pilot Boat Antwerp Belgium

published on 15 March 2022

Vessel name: Polaris ; Year built: 2012 ; Flag: Netherlands ; Homeport: Rotterdam Length: 81.2m X 13.3m ; GRT: 2501 ; Callsign: PBZN ; MMSI:245142000 ; IMO: 9496915 Type: Special Vessel / Pilot Ship A "Pilot Ship / Pilot Vessel" is a "special type" of ship in which it accommodates a certain and limited Marine Pilots (Sea, River, Harbor Pilots), it also carries small boats/crafts that are used to tender services to and from the Pilot ship. In a Pilot Vessel, the Pilots can take their time...

1

Video Pilot Leaving Ship Vigo

published on 31 March 2023

0

Article New book: The Situational Awareness & The Port Pilotage Services

published on 8 February 2021

Serkan Kahraman and Yusuf Zorba have published a new book for marine pilots. In this book, maritime pilots and shipmasters’ situational awareness levels have been analyzed using a bridge simulator system and the results have been obtained.

2

Opinion Scientific Fact: The ‘traditional’ understanding of the ship’s pivot point is wrong!

by Tim Cummins, Harbour Pilot, Portsmouth International Port - published on 9 July 2020

In fact, the pivot point that we “see” is a trick of the eye, it looks like the ship is rotating about this point but in fact it is elsewhere, a point that you cannot see.

Video Maritime Pilots' Institute

published on 4 July 2019

The Maritime Pilots Institute is the premier training facility for River Pilots employing a mix of virtual and real world facilities. Located in Covington Louisiana, we are 45 minutes from downtown New Orleans while offering the safety and amenities of small town life.
The training presents a balance between simulated locations with a variety of environmental conditions and manned scale models of cargo ships in a series of lakes with docking and currents and live factors such as wind and...

0

Article Pilots and VTS operators working together to improve maritime safety

published on 2 February 2022

The Norwegian Coastal Administration has signed an agreement with Aboa Mare to provide a new
course for pilots and VTS operators. By practising together in a simulator, maritime safety along the
Norwegian coast will be reinforced.

0

Video ETA and EMPA Efficient and safe towage operations

published on 31 August 2022

The European Tugowners Association in collaboration with the European Maritime Pilots Association has produced this informative video on efficient and safe towage operations. These guidelines address the main factors affecting the safety of harbour towage operations such as good communications between pilots, ship captains and tugmasters.

2

Video Pickup the marine pilot

published on 17 September 2021

Marine pilot

0

Article Update: "Pilot Ladder Safety" by Herman Broers (07-2021)

by Herman Broers - published on 6 July 2021

Here is the latest version of the professional handbuch of "pilot Ladder Safety" for the rigging and the use of pilot ladders by Herman Broers from July 2021.

0