Formosabulk Clement: ATSB published investigation report

published on 22 September 2023 94 -

In August 2021, during the COVID-19 pandemic, Formosabulk Clement diverted to Brisbane, Queensland for crew change, to be completed to/from a launch via the combination pilot ladder. At the time, Queensland was the easiest jurisdiction in Australia for ships to conduct crew change due to the State’s extensive quarantine arrangements for transporting and accommodating seafarers. By 1833 on 9 August, 8 persons and their luggage had been successfully transferred from the launch PT Transporter to the ship located at an outer anchorage. The launch skipper then drove the launch a short distance off the ship for a short break.

By this time, the ship had turned about the anchor and the boarding side of the ship came under the influence of the forces of wind and sea. After receiving supervisor advice to attempt the transfer again, the launch skipper took the launch back toward the boarding area to assess whether the conditions were suitable. On board Formosabulk Clement, the departing chief mate (dCM) saw the approaching launch and went down the access ladders and onto the vertical pilot ladder in anticipation of boarding. At about 1838, as the dCM waited on the ladder and the launch came close alongside, a large wave passed down the side of the ship and lifted the launch higher than expected. The dCM was struck by the launch and knocked into the sea. Despite being quickly recovered on board, they received fatal injuries.

The investigation found that the open water conditions at the anchorage, were marginal but, within a lee created by the ship, they were suitable for the transfer to occur. However, as the skipper brought the launch alongside to assess conditions, the transfer area was no longer in a lee and waves were acting against the ship’s side, increasing in height as they passed along it.

Coincident breakdowns in communications between, and within, the ship and the launch resulted in the ship’s master, the dCM, the launch skipper and the launch deckhand having different understandings of the significance and intent of the launch returning alongside the ship.

In addition, the dCM went down the boarding ladders in preparation to board the launch without the knowledge or agreement of either the ship’s master or the launch skipper. The dCM was then in a vulnerable position when the launch was lifted on the higher than expected wave.

The investigation also found that plans and details of how the transfer was to be controlled and progress when the launch was alongside were not adequately shared between all parties in the time available as the launch approached the ship. Neither the shipping company nor the launch company had in place procedures to ensure that such information was shared before the ship arrived at the anchorage.

As a consequence, different interpretations and misunderstandings of the plan and expectations of the people involved in the transfer, particularly those in positions of influence over the progress of the transfer, were not identified and addressed.
What's your opinion on this?
Login or register to write comments and join the discussion!

Article Jacobsen Pilot Service and Los Angeles Pilot Station publish notice to all ships

published on 15 August 2020

Jacobsen Pilot Service and Los Angeles Pilot Station published a notice to all ships to inspect pilot ladders before the pilot boards.

Reason is an incident happened at the port of long beach in July 2020. Pilot ladder rope broke while the pilot was on the ladder - luckily the pilot was able to hold on.


Article New Pilot Ladder Magnet Is Switchable

published on 29 June 2021

On the back of the long-standing success of the Yellow-Mag ll Pilot Ladder Magnet worldwide, Serpent & Dove—Applied Magnetics is introducing its patented Yellow-Mag lll Switchable Pilot Ladder Magnet.


Video Pilot Ladder Safety Webinar by The Nautical Institute

published on 12 May 2022

The Nautical Institute (NI) and the International Maritime Pilots’ Association (IMPA) have been concerned for many years at the needlessly high rate of Pilot Ladder casualties. The NI is continuously reminded of the problem from its Members and through its Mariners’ Alerting and Reporting Scheme (MARS). The issue features frequently in our publications, and we recently dedicated an edition of our award winning magazine The Navigator to the topic, emphasising the importance of good...


Article Tug Books available again

published on 8 January 2021

All three books, formerly published at ABR Company can be ordered now at


Opinion Bow Truster Effect on Ship's Headway

by Capt. Hugues Cauvier - published on 14 July 2022

When the bow thruster has been in operation for a while, pilots often notice that the ship not only turns but also gains speed. But why is this? Opinion by Capt. Hugues Cauvier.


Video The Hair-Raising Career of a Chesapeake Bay Pilot

published on 15 September 2020

Chesapeake Bay pilots guide massive cargo ships safely through the Bay's channels every day, but boarding them on a ladder attached to a moving ship is nothing short of breathtaking. Watch the video from a retired Bay Pilot.


Article Finland's Ministry of Transport and Communications launches project to reform Pilotage Act

published on 7 April 2021

The Ministry of Transport and Communications has launched a project to reform the Pilotage Act. The aim is that the new legislation would enter into force at the start of 2023.


Opinion A few words about pilot safety and Merry Christmas

by Frank Diegel - published on 23 December 2021

My personal impression is that a lot has changed in terms of safety in the last two years. Non-compliance with current legislation that directly affects the safety of pilots is now no longer tolerated by many stakeholders. Something is happening. And that is a good thing.


Article China's first fully electric tugboat delivered in Lianyungang

published on 22 August 2021

On August 16, the first domestic fully electric tugboat "Yungang Electric Tug No. 1" independently built by Lianyungang Port Holding Group was delivered for trial operation in Lianyungang, Jiangsu.


Video 57th EMPA Meeting Rome 2023 - Official Video

published on 1 November 2022

Official presentation video of the 57th EMPA Meeting Rome 2023
April 24th - 28th, 2023