Opinion

The IMPA Pilot Ladder Poster: Suggestions for Improvements


by Arie Palmers - published on 31 December 2020 5490 -

The article was published first on the AIMPA Journal Issue VI from December 2020. Graphic by IMPA.

The well known pilot ladder poster is displayed on the bridge of every ship nowadays. Often another copy of the poster is displayed at the pilot boarding point. Crews rather use this poster to install the pilot boarding arrangement than reading another set of rules and regulations, after all a picture tells us more than a 1000 words.

In this article I would like to share my thoughts on this pilot ladder poster. Is it as good as we think or is there room for improvement? By taking you through this poster step by step I hope to explain what needs to be changed to make it similar to IMO an SOLAS regulations.

Pilot ladder poster issued by IMPA

I will tick of a number of improvements and get into a very important issue more extensively.
poster by IMPA
poster by IMPA
poster by IMPA
poster by IMPA

Combination arrangement section:

  • Pilot steps up from the ladder to the platform, where he should step only sideways.
  • Pilot mark has been placed in the wrong position with the result some ship’s do the same thing.
  • Someone on the platform welcoming the pilot. The only place where this is mentioned is on the poster, nowhere else. Imho he could better stay on board instead of taking risks.
  • Gangway is secured to the hull by means of rope, a magnet is also allowed. Similar for the  ladder: secured by magnets, but rope is also allowed.

Bulwark section:

  • Pilot ladder without thimble eyes at the top end, secured with a wrong knot, similar for the sideropes.

Figure A,B and C:

  • Drawing suggests pad eyes are the only solution to guide the ladder from vertical to horizontal, as we know more ways are possible.
  • IMO A.1045(27) states in 7.4.2: “The pilot ladder should be secured to a strongpoint, independent of the pilot ladder winch reel”. Not the case in any of the 3 figures.
  • IMO A.1045(27) states is 7.4.3: ”the pilot ladder should be secured at deck level inside the ship opening or, when located on the ship’s upper deck at a distance of not less than 915 mm measured horizontally from the ship’s side inwards”. Not the case or made clear in any of the 3 figures.
  • In figure C, the ladder is not secured to the ship’s hull 1,5m above the platform as required.

The most dangerous remark on the poster

Let’s now focus on the most dangerous remark on the poster, the 9 m freeboard….
In the combination section is printed: “A pilot ladder requires a climb of not less than 1,5m and not more than 9m.”
This suggests that a pilot is allowed to climb a 9m ladder despite the required height above the water. Should, as for example, the pilot boat require the ladder to be rigged at a height of 3.5 meters above the water as we do in our region when we get boarded by swath, this would mean an additional climb of 9 meters would be allowed, which makes 12,5 meters in total.

Absolutely dangerous as the table below explains:
Height equals speed and danger
Height equals speed and danger
Height equals speed and danger
Height equals speed and danger
SOLAS ch. V reg.23 tells us very clearly in 3.3.1: a pilot ladder requiring a climb of not less than 1.5 m and not more than 9 m above the surface of the water so positioned and secured that...

This is quite different than the maximum climb of 9 meters the pilot ladder poster mentions. People have died falling from heights. Dropping from a height of more than 9 m will most certainly result into fatal injuries. Falling from lesser heights gives you a chance of survival. The table below in which I put dropping height in relation to speed illustrates this. Dropping from a height of even 3m will result in a final dropping speed of almost 28 km/h before you’ll hit the deck… from 10 meters even 50km/h, like driving into a wall.
Editor's note:
Opinion pieces reflect the personal opinion of individual authors. They do not allow any conclusions to be drawn about a prevailing opinion in the respective editorial department. Opinion pieces might be deliberately formulated in a pronounced or even explicit tone and may contain biased arguments. They might be intended to polarise and stimulate discussion. In this, they deliberately differ from the factual articles you typically find on this platform, written to present facts and opinions in as balanced a manner as possible.
sea, river, harbor pilot (westerschelde, oosterschelde and adjacent coastal area) active marine pilot - Loodswezen - NEDERLANDSE LOODSENCORPORATIE


50 years old, without a proper birthday party this year ( thank you corona..) 12 years as a pilot 2 years offshore/tugboats 8 years with juvenile delinquents mv Koningin Juliana, mv Smal Agt 8 years Navy: minehunter, explosive ordnance clearance 2 years army: artillery sergeant

Join the conversation...

Login or register to write comments and join the discussion!
René Hartung Lotsenbrüderschaft NOK II Kiel / Lübeck / Flensburg, Germany
on 11 April 2022, 15:26 UTC

Good points by Arie Palmers - (as usual 😉).

Whereas in my pilotage area we do not get a lot of vessels with a freeboard of more than 9 metres, I anyway completely agree on the last point. Having to climb 9 metres is bad enough - falling 9 metres + the heigt of the ladder is surely lethal
0

Sr. Manager Pilotage Kuong Chiing Tiong Maritime Pilots Malaysia - MPM, Brunei
on 1 January 2021, 14:37 UTC

Arie has done a good job! Bravo!
IMPA should consider to impose a new requirement for any new ship building, Lift or Elevator should be fit for those vessel with very high Navigational Bridge . It is unfair/safe for old and experienced Pilot to climb such a height!
1

Read more...

Video IMPA Seminar on Maritime Pilots and Pilotage

published on 10 November 2022

The Seminar aims to inform Member States, intergovernmental organizations and non-governmental organizations in consultative status with IMO about the societal value of maritime pilots and pilotage as a public service. The IMO Secretary-General has recognised maritime pilots as having always been vital to ensuring the safety of navigation in key ports and shipping lanes globally and playing a crucial role in sustaining the global supply chain using specialized knowledge and expertise....

1

Article Origins of the IMPA pilot mark

by Kevin Vallance deep sea pilot and author - published on 24 October 2019

There are many things in both our everyday and professional lives which we take for granted and never question the origins of, an example of this might be the IMPA recommended ‘pilot mark or pilot line’, which is sometimes seen on the side of vessels indicating where a vessels freeboard exceeds 9 metres.

4

Article 1,000 ways to secure a Pilot Ladder

by Arie Palmers, Netherlands - published on 10 January 2020

From that moment on I have been keeping a tally of the non compliant boarding arrangements I see in front of me on a daily base, and off course I participate in the annual safety campaign, conducted by IMPA each october.

0

Article Support Marine-Pilots.com by becoming a supporting member

published on 8 December 2022

For the past three years, our mission has been to curate daily news, job offers and informative videos. What started as a small idea over breakfast has become an institution within the pilot community.

3

Article Santander Pilots ISPO certified (since July 2020)

by ISPO - International Standard for Maritime Pilot Organisations - published on 17 November 2020

The ISPO is a quality and safety management system produced for pilots by pilots and provides performance criteria for Risk Management, Training & Qualification, Pilot Operations, Customer Relations and Emergency Preparedness.

1

Article ABB to power first fully electric U.S. tugboat for maximum efficiency and zero-emission operations

published on 30 July 2021

ABB will deliver an integrated electric propulsion system and advanced vessel control technology for Crowley’s pioneering eWolf tug, built for sustainable and safe operations at the Port of San Diego.

1

Video Safehaven Marine Interceptor 48 pilot boat for the Gdynia Pilots in Poland

published on 6 July 2020

Video by Safehaven Marine / Frank Kowalski
Here’s a cool video of the latest Interceptor 48 pilot boat we’ve launched for the Gdynia Pilots in Poland. We captured some nice alongside ship footage during the sea trials and had a chance to test out our new drone ‘catch net’ on Thunder Child.

0

Article Hwalein Marine Pilot got accident while boarding

by Video found on YouTube - published on 8 February 2020

Another accident was reported on YouTube on Feb. 3rd 2020 by akif pradias.
"This video shown how's hwalein pilot got accident while boarding the vessel, its teach us to be more carefully during pilot transfer..."

0

Video A Day in the life of a Port Pilot

published on 4 July 2019

This what a normal work day looks like for a port pilot.
A 24 hour shift shown in 11 minutes.
Recorded in Santa Marta, Colombia.

0

Video Pilot Boarding - Accidentology (2001- 2021) - French Maritime Pilots' Association

published on 10 May 2023

The accidentology survey conducted in France between 2001 and 2021 found that pilots face significant risks during transfer phases while embarking or disembarking from ships that they are required to serve. To ensure their safety and improve transfers, pilots develop specific procedures and safety protocols and equip themselves with the necessary gear. These safety measures are presented in the following film that is intended for both novice and experienced pilot boat drivers and pilots,...

1