Article

A Collision that Should Not Have Happened


by Marine-Pilots.com - published on 10 April 2025 1401 -

Based on MAIB Safety Digest 1/2025, Case 12, published April 2025 by the UK Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB).

The digest provides anonymised, instructive case studies from recent maritime accidents, aiming to raise safety awareness and promote learning across the industry. This particular case involves a serious collision between a cargo vessel and a pilot launch during a night-time departure — a scenario that highlights critical failures in pilotage coordination and bridge resource management.

During a routine late-night departure from port, a general cargo vessel got underway with a pilot embarked. The vessel cast off and began maneuvering through a constrained harbour channel toward open sea, guided by the pilot. The operation required precise coordination due to the narrow exit between two breakwaters.

As the ship progressed, the pilot became absorbed in a VHF radio conversation with port control. The discussion was not related to the vessel's navigation but focused on logistical arrangements for the pilot's next assignment. The dialogue soon devolved into unrelated chatter. The master, while able to hear the exchange, did not understand the content, as it was conducted entirely in the local language.
Credit: UK MAIB
Credit: UK MAIB
Credit: UK MAIB
Credit: UK MAIB
With the vessel on a steady outbound course, the pilot instructed the master to increase speed to 12 knots. Ahead, the pilot launch was making slow way out of the harbour, presumably positioning itself for the pilot’s disembarkation. There was no communication between the vessels regarding movements or intentions.

Approaching the narrowest part of the channel, the master noticed the pilot launch closing in dangerously on the port bow. When prompted by the master, the pilot attempted to establish contact with the launch. However, at that moment, the launch unexpectedly altered course to starboard — directly across the cargo ship’s path.

Despite immediate engine and helm orders, a collision was unavoidable. The cargo ship struck the pilot launch’s starboard quarter. The launch took on water rapidly and sank. All four launch crew members escaped uninjured and were rescued by two nearby tugs.

Key Lessons:
  • Bridge Resource Management (BRM): Effective coordination between the pilot and bridge team is essential. In this case, the pilot was disengaged, and the bridge team failed to assertively integrate him into the navigational decision-making process.
  • Situational Awareness: The pilot launch crew was distracted and failed to maintain a proper lookout as required by COLREGs Rule 5. Likewise, the bridge team missed opportunities to issue sound signals that could have alerted the launch in time.
  • Communication Protocols: There was no proactive VHF communication between the pilot vessel and the cargo ship. Five short blasts — the standard danger signal — were not used.
  • Risk-Based Decision-Making: Despite the accident, the master made the correct call to maintain control of the vessel and clear the narrow channel to avoid further hazard. He returned to port as soon as it was safe.
Conclusion:

This case serves as a sobering reminder that pilotage is not a routine formality — it is a high-stakes, shared responsibility. Pilots must be fully integrated into the bridge team and maintain complete situational awareness. Masters and bridge teams, in turn, must remain assertively involved and not hesitate to challenge or question unclear actions. Coordination failures, especially during high-risk phases such as departures in confined waters, can rapidly escalate into major incidents — as this collision clearly shows.


Source: UK Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB), Safety Digest 1/2025, Case 12: "A Crunchy Exit", published April 2025. Available at: www.gov.uk/maib
What's your opinion on this?
Login or register to write comments and join the discussion!
Read more...

Article Marine Accident Investigation Branch (UK): Report 2020

published on 14 June 2021

The Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB) examines and investigates all types of marine accidents to or on board UK vessels worldwide, and other vessels in UK territorial waters. Here is the annual report of 2020.

0

Article Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB) Annual Report 2021 published

published on 10 June 2022

The UK Marine Accident Investigation Branch’s (MAIB) has published their latest annual report showing that pilot ladders remain a safety issue for workers.

0

Article Best practice on rigging pilot ladders (UK MAIB)

published on 7 July 2022

On the occasion of the Maritime Safety Week (July 4-10), UK MAIB’s inspector Bill Evans refers to the issue of unsafe pilot ladders, a concern that has been regularly voiced by the industry.

2

Article Filipino crew died trying to assist pilot boarding

published on 4 April 2023

A Filipino crew member of a Capesize bulk carrier HELLASSHIP fell into water while trying to assist pilot boarding bulk carrier in rough weather, off Gijon, Spain.

1

Opinion A deliberately sabotaged Pilot Ladder

by Arie Palmers - published on 16 March 2022

A court sentenced a captain to a total of 30 months imprisonment: It had been proven beyond doubt that the side ropes had been manipulated to make a ship inspection more difficult or to prevent it.

3

Video Meet the weather our crews and the RNLI faced when the Thea II grounded

published on 21 August 2020

Meet the weather our HM Coastguard Humberside helicopter, RNLI - Humber Lifeboat Station and emergency tugs faced on Saturday when the Thea II grounded. The good news is that she refloated without any pollution reported and has now berthed safely into King George Docks, Hull where she awaits a visit from our MCA surveyors and the Marine Accident Investigation Branch #allsafe

0

Article Ramsgate RNLI called to rescue beached boat at Broadstairs

by www.theisleofthanetnews.com - published on 9 December 2021

Ramsgate RNLI crews were called in to help a pilot boat beached at Broadstairs last night (December 7).

0

Article Turkish pilot loses his life on duty

published on 5 February 2024

The pilot fell into the sea from the cross at around 04.30 (04.02.2024) in the morning, while being transferred to the Cook Islands-The ppilot flagged 176 m long ship called NEW SIHAM, at the southern entrance of the Bosphorus.

2

Video Near miss: VALDIVIA dangerously approached beach in Vlissingen, NL

published on 28 May 2020

Container vessel ALDIVIA (IMO 9333395) was dangerously close to public beach at Vlissingen Netherlands, on May 21, while heading out to sea, en route from Antwerp to Helsinki Finland.
The cause of dangerous approach is unknown, but the ship wasn’t detained, she continued her voyage.

0