Article

Suez Canal chief hints ‘mistake’ by captain could be linked to Ever Given incident


published on 14 April 2021 2779 -

Photo by Suez Canal Authority

The chairman of the Suez Canal Authority has suggested a possible mistake by the captain of the Ever Given could have led to the grounding of the giant container ship in the waterway last month.

After the grounding incident, the canal authority is pondering modifications to its physical operations. Recently, the Suez Canal received the largest dredger in all of middle-east: Mohab Mamish, onboard the heavy transport vessel Xiang Rui Kou.

They are including larger salvage tugs, bigger cranes, and the widening of the narrow southern section of the canal. On the other hand, SCA authorities deny bearing any responsibility for the grounding, with Lt. Gen. Rabie speculating that the vessel's master may be to blame recently.

He said, “Maybe the captain made a mistake in a specific request, such as the rudder or speed, which could have led to that. Even when orders are issued by the guide [pilot], the captain has the right to change them or use any route or speed other than what the guide says. There was no error or responsibility on the part of the [SCA]"

Right now, investigations are underway into the incident. Egyptian authorities have retrieved data from the EVER GIVEN's VDR, and are examining the evidence currently.

Join the conversation...

Login or register to write comments and join the discussion!
Capt. Daniel Cwirko Poland
on 21 May 2021, 06:14 UTC

I'm afraid Master's are sadly scape goats of the maritime industry as it is most convenient (and beneficial?) for all parties to just blame the Master. It's about time for the industry to realize shipping is a complicated buisness and many parties share responsibilities. Why not to blame the pilot (advisor - what he was doing on board? Is he only coming to collect Marlboro?), Suez Canal Authorities (for allowing the transit in bad weather), owner/operator (commercial pressure), etc? Too complicated and too expensive. Blame the Captain and problem solved. Insurance will pay the money and everybody will be happy. Interestingly SCA by taking actions to prevent similar incidents in the furure admitted they feel guilty. And they rightly should. It's also time to held pilots accountable. It can (and some would say must) be done - Panama Canal is great example here.
2

Captain Robert de Roos Loodswezen Rotterdam - Rijnmond, Netherlands
on 16 April 2021, 11:23 UTC

Agree with Wade Armstrong: Training, training and training, theoretical and on the simulator.
Secondly special restrictions for passage should be considered. If not, it will just happen again.
1

Captain Wade Armstrong Hawaii Pilots' Association, USA
on 15 April 2021, 07:41 UTC

Of course the Suez Canal Authority would try to blame the Master. The Suez Canal Pilot almost certainly had the conn, and was primarily responsible for the grounding.
4

A community member on 14 April 2021, 14:16 UTC

This comment has been removed.

Read more...

Article Mega container ship hard aground in Suez Canal (incl. Video)

published on 24 March 2021

Ultra Large Container Vessel EVER GIVEN ran aground in Suez Canal north of Suez, at around 0600 UTC Mar 23, shortly after entering Canal in northbound convoy.

1

Video Giant Container Ship EVER GIVEN grounded and blocked Suez canal

published on 24 March 2021

Giant Container Ship EVER GIVEN grounded and blocked Suez canal AIS data shows the MV Ever Given is stuck sideways within the canal, preventing ships from passing in either direction,Several tugs have been on scene for several hours working to dislodge the ship ,An ultra-large containership is aground and blocking ship traffic in the Suez Canal

0

Video Stuck at sea: Mega cargo ship wedged in Suez Canal causes traffic jam

published on 25 March 2021

Tug boats and a digger struggle to free a mega cargo ship, blocking one of the world's busiet shipping pathways.
Dozens of ships are stuck because a container ship almost half a kilometre long is wedged across the waterway.

0

Video PTR Pilot ladder

published on 6 November 2020

0

Article Swift Action By UK Maritime Pilots Avoids Blocking Southampton Water

published on 31 January 2023

The United Kingdom Maritime Pilots Association (UKMPA), is the representative professional body for Maritime Pilots in the United Kingdom. Almost every ship entering or leaving a port, is required under UK law to engage a duly Authorised Maritime Pilot, who either boards the vessel in port or at sea and takes conduct of the safe navigation of that vessel. This undertaking is critical to protecting the country’s national infrastructure and environment from damage or pollution, supporting the UK’s economy, and ensuring the safe, timely and efficient movement of all trade.

1

Article Swedish Club: Pilot ladder in poor condition

published on 3 August 2022

In it´s August 2022 monthly safety scenario, the Swedish Club describes an accident where a pilot had fallen into the water, after one of the side ropes of the ladder broke.

1

Video Pilot boat catches fire in Brazil

published on 17 January 2022

A pilot boat caught fire near the entrance of the Port of Recife, on Saturday morning (15 January). The fire would have started around 11h. In a note, the port authority explained that the two people who were in the pilot boat were rescued by another pilot boat "Serrambi".
The causes of the accident had not yet been identified, but would be investigated.

0

Article Skipper and pilot died in pilot boat collision, Kobe

published on 27 September 2022

Pilot boat with 5 people on board collided with breakwater at Kobe Port, Japan, at around 0300 Tokyo time Sep 4. 52-year old skipper of the boat, and 71-year old pilot, died in the collision, 3 crew were seriously injured.

1

Opinion Pilots are not Advisors to Masters

by Karolina Cirjak, Consultant Master Mariner at KC Maritime Consultancy Ltd. - published on 30 November 2024

This article was first published back in February 2022: According to the International Group of P & I Clubs’ “Report on P&I claims involving vessels under pilotage 1999-2019”, over the last twenty years, there were 1,046 incidents in which pilot error either caused or contributed to those events.

7

Video Pilot Boat "CATAMARÁN ANTARES", "KENNADI",  29.12.2024

published on 6 January 2025

#PilotVessel "CATAMARÁN ANTARES"/ On board #BulkCarrierShip "KENNADI" #ZonaComún #RioDeLaPlata #Argentina/ 29th. December 2024 - 17:15 Local Time.- On this video (with original sound), you can watch the Pilot Vessel "CATAMARÁN ANTARES", arrived at #boardingpoint #ZonaComún #RioDeLaPlata to change Pilots  (Disembarking Maneuver of the Rio de la Plata Pilots and Embarking Manuever of Rio Paraná Pilots).- This video was filmed on board the following Vessel: Bulk Carrier Ship "KENNADI" - Call...

0