Opinion

What value do 10K+ Professionals add to Safety of Manoeuvres


by CAPTAIN REGINALDO PANTOJA - published on 29 September 2022 240 -

Text and images by Maritime Pilot of Rio Grande/Brazil Harbour Reginaldo Pantoja


HIGH-PERFORMANCE TEAMS IN PILOTAGE
Pilotage is an essential service, it requires high value-added technical expertise, constant training, and teamwork.
Under the management of a high-performance team, pilotage services' safety, efficiency and productivity significantly contribute to harmonizing the interests of maritime trade and the protection of the sensitive environment of ports.
Special missions require skilled and well-trained professionals to perform them.
A high-performance team preparation invests time and practice with a methodology to reach a level of excellence compatible with maritime trade demands.


TRAINING
According to many training experts, including Malcom Gladwell, from his book Outliers: Story of Success, 10.000 hours is the point in which a standard professional acquires the qualities necessary to perform any work with master skill. Let's assume that marine pilots need approximately 10,000 manoeuvres (10K) to reach equivalent level. After reaching this point, the professional has adequate knowledge to manage new situations learned with the competence taught by training.


HOW TO CONSTRUCT AN ACCIDENT (THE FLEXIBLE METHOD)
Some professionals develop their own styles and apply them with questionable flexibilities as time passes.
The accidents result from styles that come from the professional's comfort zone.
This type of attitude leads some of these professionals to continue the path of repeating their flexible methodology, increasing the margin of error, and reducing the possibility for efficient risk management.
Playing as a professional in the comfort zone is simpler.
The flexible methodology does not consider the stumbles and warnings of near missing. It does not address essential details in time to avoid the assembling of a future accident.
Lessons learned and protocols are partially assimilated more by fright than by a rigid mandatory process.
The styles that do not adopt the ballast of norms/resolutions impede the essential training necessary for applying immediate actions in the event of an error chain.
The continuation of training outside the proper methods results that, even in the 10K+ condition, some professionals cannot manage a contingency situation properly.
Have they been trained exhaustively to react in time to stop it?
Training skills to apply a standard operational procedure is impossible without proper methodology and methodical training, including contingency in adequate time.


SAFETY VALUES
In the case of marine pilots, the basis that maintains the level of training necessary to perform the manoeuvres safely is the continuous repetition of the technical methodology recommended in norms and resolutions.
The dimensions of the vessels are increasing. The effects of the current, wind, shallow water and others are considerable during their passage along the channels until the berth.
Many TCPAs and CPAs requiring precise risk management are floating around from PBP until the berth and vice versa.
The IMO Resolution A.960 (23) must be entirely followed and practiced by professionals who manage risks so that its content can have the effects foreseen in its adoption. It is the master guide for shiphandlers.
Marine pilot refresher courses should prioritize checklists and standard operating procedures.
They are essential tools for risk management.
To add safety value to the process, the ship handling specialists need the proper training and follow-up over time to help them reach the 10K+ phase with the competence that congested maritime port traffic expects from them.
One of the strengths of high-performance teams is training focused on the skills needed to perform the job safely and quickly.


ACCIDENTS WITH EXPERIENCIED MARITIME PILOTS (10K+ PILOTS)
As an instructor of refresher courses for pilots, I read many analyses of accidents where the captain and pilot are professionals of more than 10,000 manoeuvres experience (10K+).
The more we delve into the analysis of accidents, the more we find that we can avoid a significant percentage of these just by applying the simple tools recommended in the IMO Resolution A.960 (23).
Considering my restrict analysis of accidents involving 10K+ professionals, the absence of a checklist and a standard operating procedure stand out among the contributing factors observed.


THE 10K+ SHIPHANDLERS DOING THEIR BEST
What value do 10K+ shiphandlers add to the safety of the manoeuvres?
After all, they are white-haired professionals, and the captains trust them. Their fellow 10K- shiphandlers see them as role models.
We need to train, adjust, create, share, and navigate with the safety of those who know that the game of manoeuvres requires competence to finish successfully.
Manoeuvre after manoeuvre, 10K+ marine pilots should take the route that turns them into old and experienced pilots.
Otherwise, as time goes on, they will only be old pilots.
Editor's note:
Opinion pieces reflect the personal opinion of individual authors. They do not allow any conclusions to be drawn about a prevailing opinion in the respective editorial department. Opinion pieces might be deliberately formulated in a pronounced or even explicit tone and may contain biased arguments. They might be intended to polarise and stimulate discussion. In this, they deliberately differ from the factual articles you typically find on this platform, written to present facts and opinions in as balanced a manner as possible.
Dock Master, Mooring Master, Towing Master, Ship to Ship operations, ocean sailingoats, active marine pilot - Praticagem Rio Grande


manoeuvering and sailing is the reason to live

Join the conversation...

Login or register to write comments and join the discussion!
RC
Ricardo Caballero Vega Panama Canal Pilots Association, Panama
on 30 September 2022, 14:11 UTC

A great article. It points out a difficult aspect of piloting. There is always this question on how a a pilot that has proven himself efficient and safe becomes involved in an accident. When complancency becomes part of a procedure, even if subtle, it also becomes the potential cause of an accident. Or it could be the unnotticed link of the chain that lead to an accident. This is why constant training, sharing of information, establishing procedures and reviewing them in a regular basis, is a necessitty. Making the distinction between old and experienced, is making the distinction between safe piloting and just piloting.
1

Read more...

Video M+ Maritime I ECDIS Safety Settings | Full Video | Episode 1

published on 11 July 2020

M+ releases the 1st video of ECDIS competency series on “Safety Settings” presented by Safe Lanes. Use them for training crew, enhance safety standards & professional knowledge. Stay tuned for our upcoming series on ECDIS competency, Anchor losses, Incidents, PCS & vetting preparations & Human Elements training. These “first of it's kind” learning videos are based on PSC & vetting observations to provide solutions & enhance your professional competency. Pls feel free to connect to get a...

2

Video Professor Patrick Hudson: Safety Culture and Leadership

published on 23 February 2023

Professor Patrick Hudson discusses safety culture and leadership.

0

Video ARPA Ground & Sea Stabilisation (Speed over ground & through water) |

published on 11 July 2020

M+ releases it's next interactive video on 'ARPA Ground & Sea Stabilisation; an explanation of 'Speed over ground & Speed through water. Use this video for training crew, enhance safety standards & professional knowledge. Stay tuned for our upcoming series on ECDIS competency, Anchor losses, Incidents, PCS & vetting preparations & Human Elements training. These ‘first of it's kind’ learning videos are based on PSC & vetting observations to provide solutions & enhance your professional...

0

Video Marine pilotage - a pilot's boat trip in Helsinki (Finland)

published on 28 September 2021

This video is filmed in 2015, edited 2021.
A maritime pilot, marine pilot, harbor pilot, port pilot, ship pilot, or simply pilot, is a mariner who maneuvers ships through dangerous or congested waters, such as harbors or river mouths. They are navigational experts possessing knowledge of the particular waterway such as its depth, currents, and hazards, as well as being experts in handling ships of all types and size. A Maritime pilot is an expert ship handler who is licensed or authorised...

0

Video From Nordkai (Ems) towards the lake

published on 14 December 2020

Take a ride!
On the "EDDAFJORD" it goes in time-lapse through the Great Sea Lock in Emden down the Ems. Video courtesy of the captain.

0

Video IMPA CHIRP Safety Campaign 2024 Video

published on 16 September 2024

IMPA and CHIRP Maritime have collaborated on a video to support the 2024 IMPA Safety Campaign and Survey which takes place 1 - 15 October 2024. More details can be found at www.impahq.org.

0

Article Watch out for hydrodynamic effects when manoeuvring your ship in restricted waterways

by SWZ|Maritime - published on 14 October 2021

Research on hydrodynamic interaction indicates that if the speed of the ship near a bank is too high, the rudder may be less able to cope with the forces induced and control will be lost. The Nautical Institute highlights this in its latest Mars Report, in which an LPG carrier hit a barge being towed by a tugboat as a result of hydrodynamic forces.

1

Video Terms of Trade: Port Pilots. Port of Long Beach’s video glossary

published on 14 August 2024

We’re paying homage to some of the most skilled sailors around…Port Pilots. Learn why you always want them behind the wheel when you’re pulling into port on this edition of Terms of Trade, the Port of Long Beach’s video glossary.

0

Video Pilot boat Lorient harbor - Storm Ulla 2014

published on 18 October 2020

Approche d'un navire gros colis par mauvais temps en 2014. Pilotone Troenn de Lorient

1

Video Technique Maritime Pilots Use to Board Ships Moving on Polar Ice

published on 22 April 2025

Welcome back to the Fluctus Channel and watch with us as ship pilots get onto and off moving vessels. Fluctus is a website and YouTube channel dedicated to sea geeks. Whenever you are curious or an incorrigible lover of this mysterious world, our videos are made for you ! We publish 3 videos a week on our YouTube channel and many more articles on our website. Feel free to subscribe to not miss any of our updates and visit our website to discover additional content. Don’t forget to follow...

0