Opinion

Beyond Experience: Building the Next Generation of Maritime Pilots


by Maritime Pilot Abolfazl Farajnezam - published today 256 -

Text and pictures by Abolfazl Farajnezam, MSc,
(Maritime Leadership Consultant / Former Maritime Pilot)


Building the Next Generation of Maritime Pilots
Introduction
Maritime pilotage is essential to international trade and navigation safety. Pilot selection, hiring, and training is a comprehensive and requires noteworthy investment from both organizations and regulatory bodies. Pilot recruitment has traditionally been based on seniority, and extensive sea experience. However, a more modern approach, hiring younger, motivated candidates with structured training, offers an alternative path with compelling advantages. This article examines these two models from the perspective of an experienced maritime pilot and an organizational development expert.

Recognizing the Contributions of Maritime Pilots
The experience value in maritime pilotage cannot be questioned. Master Mariners who have spent decades at sea have a wealth of knowledge, from ship handling to navigation, stability, and emergency procedures. Their amassed knowledge has been the foundation for safe and efficient maritime operations for centuries.
However, one often-overlooked component is local knowledge. A highly experienced master mariner with massive ocean-going and sea time experience may not necessarily be aware of some local waterways, narrow channels, winds, tides, currents, and port facilities. As valuable as their experience, localized pilotage requires additional training to guarantee safe maneuvering in constrained waters. This is where an alternative hiring model gains traction—by emphasizing local knowledge development early in the pilotage training process.

The Traditional Pilot Hiring Model
Pilotage organizations have had a strict hiring process for decades. Applicants must hold a Master Mariner/Captain license and have a minimum of 10 to 15 years of sea-time to be considered. This process involves a through entrance test, including written exam, oral evaluation, practical simulation test followed by lengthy apprenticeship at the hands of senior pilots, additional concentrated simulator, on-the-job training, and ultimate licensing exams.

While this model guarantees competency, it comes with a number of challenges. Most pilots come into the career in their late 40s or 50s, which leaves few years of service. Seniority based hiring reduces the talent pool available, thus making hiring harder. The high cost and time investment required for prolonged training further complicate the hiring process. Additionally, even highly experienced mariners must undergo extensive local adaptation before becoming effective pilots, as their general maritime experience does not necessarily translate to local knowledge.
picture by author
picture by author
picture by author
picture by author
A Modern Alternative; Early Recruitment and Intensive Training
A growing number of organizations are reconsidering these requirements. Instead of recruiting only senior mariners, they are hiring younger candidates and investing in their training. In this model, candidates with at least Second Mate unlimited license and minimal sea-time requirements undergo rigorous entrance exams to assess capacity. Structured training programs then provide simulator-based ship handling instruction, beginning with smaller vessels and simpler operations before progressing to more complex tasks under experienced mentors.

Comprehensive local knowledge training ensures that new pilots become adept in specific navigational challenges from the outset. This method not only fosters a physically fit and technologically adaptable workforce but also develops a talent pool that can serve for decades within the organization.

Comparing the Two Approaches
From a cost and time efficiency perspective, the traditional model requires lengthy apprenticeships and costly experience-based training, whereas the alternative model reduces training duration by focusing on core ship handling competencies and local knowledge. Workforce durability also favors the modern approach, as early-career recruitment leads to decades of service within the organization, whereas traditional recruitment limits working years due to later career entry.

Training effectiveness differs as well. The traditional model relies heavily on accumulated sea experience, which may lack structured, standardized pilotage learning methods. In contrast, the modern approach uses advanced training tools such as simulators specified for each port and concentrated on different pilotage operations including Docking, Undocking, Ship to ship (STS), cold move and so on. Combination with real-world observation, and active mentoring from senior pilots, ensuring a more streamlined learning process.

One of the biggest contrasts between the two approaches is the balance between local knowledge, ship handling, and general maritime experience. Traditional hiring requires extensive adaptation for pilots transitioning from ocean-going experience, whereas the modern approach focuses on local expertise from the beginning, allowing for a smoother transition into pilotage. Additionally, technological adaptability is a key factor, senior recruits may struggle with evolving maritime technology, while fresher pilots are more adept at integrating electronic navigation systems, digital tools, and the uncertain future of AI.
The Role of Physical Fitness and Safety
Physical endurance is an often-overlooked factor in pilotage. Climbing pilot ladders in extreme weather, transferring between vessels, and responding to emergencies require peak physical fitness. While experience is invaluable, age-related declines in agility and endurance can pose risks.

Though comprehensive data on pilotage accidents due to age-related physical decline is limited, studies in similar high-risk professions suggest that physical ability directly impacts performance and safety. A Fresh Pilot, properly trained, may reduce incidents related to fatigue or diminished reaction times.

Supporting Evidence for the Alternative Model
Several pilotage organizations have already begun experimenting with this method, with promising results. Simulator-based training accelerates skill acquisition and builds confidence. Competency-focused selection improves performance and adaptability. Younger recruits with structured local knowledge pilotage training can match experienced pilots in efficiency within a shorter timeframe.

Conclusion: A More Sustainable Approach to Pilot Hiring
While the traditional model has served the industry, it is no longer the only supportable path. Hiring younger candidates and investing in well structured, intensive training programs ensures a wider and more sustainable talent pool. These pilots are more adaptable to modern technology and evolving maritime challenges and possess local expertise from the outset, reducing the gap between experience and efficiency.

Maritime pilotage is entering a new era, one in which experience counts and is complemented by the efficiency of modern training. Organizations that adopt the shift will not only optimize their investment but also have a qualified and strong pilot staff in the years of ahead.
Editor's note:
Opinion pieces reflect the personal opinion of individual authors. They do not allow any conclusions to be drawn about a prevailing opinion in the respective editorial department. Opinion pieces might be deliberately formulated in a pronounced or even explicit tone and may contain biased arguments. They might be intended to polarise and stimulate discussion. In this, they deliberately differ from the factual articles you typically find on this platform, written to present facts and opinions in as balanced a manner as possible.
Harbor Pilot active marine pilot


Accomplished maritime professional with extensive experience in maritime logistics, operations, and safety. Dynamic, and results-driven leader with over 10 years of experience in managing port operations and piloting more than 3,000 vessels, including container ships, tankers, Ro-Ro vessels, and bulk carriers in one of the busiest hub in Persian Gulf. In-depth knowledge of international maritime codes and conventions (SOLAS, MARPOL, ISM, SMS, ISPS) as well as national regulations, including USCG and OSHA. Currently providing expert consultancy services in operational efficiency, safety compliance, and organizational leadership for maritime and port management industries. Passionate about driving continuous improvement, building high-performing teams, and fostering business development.

Join the conversation...

Login or register to write comments and join the discussion!
Captain Peter Behling NO ORGANISATION FOUND - help us (click here), USA
today, 15:10 UTC

They my career I have worked with pilots from both systems and as a maritime professional I have always preferred the traditional method of taking mariners with real sea experience. From a masters perspective they have done the job and understand the stress and strain that the ships crew is placed under versus the turn and burn mentality of pilot brought in under “modern system”. Further more I feel this approach will cause more mariners to leave industry as experienced mariners will be left at sea and not allowing for natural procession of promotion. And then mid level officers will seek alternative employment
1

Read more...

Video Kittiwake Mersey Pilot

published on 22 December 2021

KITTIWAKE ( MMSI 232008570) is a Pilot and currently sailing under the flag of United Kingdom (UK) Here she is speeding down the River this morning.

0

Video Polaris Pilot Boat Antwerp Belgium

published on 15 March 2022

Vessel name: Polaris ; Year built: 2012 ; Flag: Netherlands ; Homeport: Rotterdam Length: 81.2m X 13.3m ; GRT: 2501 ; Callsign: PBZN ; MMSI:245142000 ; IMO: 9496915 Type: Special Vessel / Pilot Ship A "Pilot Ship / Pilot Vessel" is a "special type" of ship in which it accommodates a certain and limited Marine Pilots (Sea, River, Harbor Pilots), it also carries small boats/crafts that are used to tender services to and from the Pilot ship. In a Pilot Vessel, the Pilots can take their time...

1

Video Pilot Leaving Ship Vigo

published on 31 March 2023

0

Video Self-righting test and arrival of Pilot Boat "Hirondelle de la Manche" (2017)

published on 20 September 2021

Arrivée au Havre de la pilotine Hirondelle de la Manche

0

Opinion The last day of service for Brisbane Marine Pilots

by Brisbane Marine Pilots - published on 31 December 2021

As the sun comes up on the last day of 2021, the last shipping day for Brisbane Marine Pilots, our pilots out on the water serving the Port of Brisbane Pty Ltd, as they have done every day since 1st January 1989.

2

Video Meet Captain Lyle Donovan, a San Diego Bay pilot with the San Diego Bay Pilots Association

published on 27 May 2020

May is Maritime Month at the Port of San Diego and we are proud to highlight some of our hardworking men and women of the Working Waterfront. Meet Captain Lyle Donovan, a San Diego Bay pilot with the San Diego Bay Pilots Association. His work consists of guiding ships in and out of San Diego Bay in a safe and efficient manner. A typical day includes guiding a 650-foot car carrying vessel or a 950-foot cruise ship into San Diego Bay. This entails boarding the vessels by climbing up a ladder,...

0

Video Falmouth Pilots: Working as Maritime Pilot (Documentary 2019)

published on 30 March 2022

Documentary from 2019 by "The Sea Lad"

1

Video Awesome Video: Suez Canal-Egypt (Northbound)

published on 28 October 2021

Many of you saw the last video and we were traveling South through the canal, but this video is from our Northbound transit.
Enjoy the footage and soon I hope to be back to work again. Waiting for the results of my physical exams to clear.

0

Video Transport maritime : le rôle crucial des pilotes du St-Laurent

published on 17 October 2022

Toutes les 40 minutes, un pilote du Saint-Laurent embarque à bord d'un navire de commerce qui transite entre Montréal et Québec. 230 pilotes sont chargés de guider les embarcations dans la voie maritime : une des plus dangereuses au monde. Un métier essentiel à l'économie du Québec, qui est payant, mais qui vient avec son lot de contraintes et de stress. Catherine François nous amène à bord d'un porte-conteneur qui sillonne le fleuve. Le reportage de Catherine François au #TJ18H -- Rendez-...

1

Opinion Piloting in a Pandemic – A Personal Perspective

by William Hargreaves - published on 25 March 2021

Article and pictures by Captain W J M Hargreaves, Retired Southampton Pilot

0