Opinion

Pilot: “Adviser” and/or “Specialist”?


by Ed Verbeek - published on 27 April 2021 2880 -

Photos by Mirjam Terpstra

I have had the privilege of being at quite a number of meetings, conferences and seminars, sometimes representing The Netherlands, but mostly representing the Netherlands pilots. I have had many discussions about the role of pilots and pilot organisations, which lead me to write an article “What is the added value of pilotage?”, published in the February 2020 issue of Seaways.

It has become clear to me that only a few people actually know what pilots are doing. Even captains and mates generally only know what a pilot is doing on their (type of) ship, which can be quite different from what a pilot is doing on other (types of) ships. Just think of the difference of piloting cruise ships versus piloting Vale-Max bulkers.

By the way, this works the other way around as well: pilots often don’t realise that slowly but surely they take their own port as yardstick of how pilots work, and that isn’t necessarily an accurate picture of pilotage in general.

Still, I’m convinced that the ones who know best what pilots are doing, are pilots themselves. So I believe that it is up to pilots to communicate their role in a way that is understood by their audience, which can have very different backgrounds. If we feel that the job of pilots is misunderstood, I think that we have to evaluate our way of communicating.

An issue is that there are different legal descriptions of the job of the pilot. These roughly fall into two categories:


  • A pilot is any person, not belonging to a ship, who has the conduct thereof
  • A pilot is an adviser

These seem very different descriptions. However in most legislations which use the 2nd description, somewhere in the rules and legislations there are articles that allow, or even normalise, the pilot taking the con, so in practice the differences are not that large.

Pilots coming from a background in which the pilot is described as an “adviser” tend to use that description to explain their role on board. This article tries to assist pilot organisations with this background in thinking of an appropriate description to explain the job of maritime pilot in everyday language.

The term adviser has not been chosen lightly, there are solid legal reasons to do so.

However in ordinary conversations I have noticed that the use of the term “adviser” may lead to a misunderstanding of the role of pilots. This can happen with people who are not actively involved in bridge activities, and even with captains and mates of ship types on which pilots fulfil an advisory role, and who do not realise that this is only part of the spectrum of a pilots job.

The term “adviser” can easily lead to a view that pilots stand in the corner of the bridge with a cup of coffee or tea and say to the captain: “the current is setting you to the North, here left, there right, did you see that barge? There is your berth”. I have met intelligent, responsible people who couldn’t understand why we “poach” skilled master mariners and give them one year training for that kind of a job. Neither are they are convinced that a masters license is required, nor do they understand why pilots want to come on board. From their perspective, as a pilot is ‘only’ an adviser and as he advices only about the local conditions, in these days it would be “easy” to give this advice from shore.

To avoid such associations I have started to use the term ”specialist” to explain the role of a pilot. This term can be used irrespective if the pilots are seen as “having the con” or as “an adviser”. The captain can be viewed as “general manager”. In those countries where the legal status of the pilot is “adviser”, the captain (within legal boundaries) decides how to employ this specialist. This can be either in a direct operational capacity or in a more advisory role.

For the sake of completeness, these are the descriptions of the terms as in the on-line Cambridge dictionary:


  • Adviser: someone whose job is to give advice about a subject:
  • Specialist: someone who has a lot of experience, knowledge, or skill in a particular subject; or

someone who limits his or her studying or work to a particular area of knowledge,    and who is an expert in that area:


  • Expert: -a person with a high level of knowledge or skill relating to a particular subject or an activity;         

                       or 

                      -having or showing a lot of knowledge or skill:

The word “specialist” carries the notion that the person has had additional education and training, and has amassed experience. It reduces the notion that pilots are “only advisers” and advice only of local conditions. Aspects like shiphandling are better covered by terms like “specialist” or “expert” than by “adviser”.

This description of “specialist” needs to be expanded to a description of the role of the pilot and pilot organisation.  I have tried to do that in the earlier mentioned article in Seaways. I’ll shortly mention some aspects, and refer to the article for those who want to read my arguments more in depth.

Most discussion about pilotage revolves around  the individual pilot on the individual ship. Often overlooked is the influence pilotage has on the traffic flow: pilotage as a system. Pilots can understand the problems of other ships(-types) first hand, as they have been on board all these (type of) ships. The movements of ships with pilots, all with the same training, are predictable. Pilots have the opportunity to discuss formally and informally (meetings, pilots office/boat etc) so that consistency is improved.

Which leads to the importance of pilot organisations, which provide education and training, information, facilitate meetings etc. to keep the specialist up to standard, and promote predictability.

Another aspect that deserves attention is the role of pilots as risk managers, to minimise the risk that the ship presents to port (and infrastructure).

When I talk about the role of pilots, typically I’ll say that pilots are specialists, educated, trained and supported by the pilot organisation,. Because of their specialist knowledge and experience (local and  manoeuvring) they can anticipate the critical parts of the voyage, both for the own ship as for all ships they are going to meet.

Pilots have developed strategies to have maximum chance on a safe and expedient passage under all hydrological and meteorological circumstances (including aborting or not commencing the passage).
They have seen so many bridge teams in action, that they are able to identify the weaker areas of the bridge team and are able to give support in the areas needed (to indicate the difference between bridge team and pilot, I call the combined team “Team on the Bridge”).

I hope that I have given you food for thought on how to verbalise the role of the pilot, who is supported by the organisation, without neglecting the larger picture of pilotage as a system.

In normal conversations we generally do not use legal terms. Outside of legal proceedings, if the role of the pilot is mentioned maybe you could consider to avoid the use of the legal term “adviser” and instead use words like “specialist” or “expert”, which are closer to the operational reality and can be used whichever the legal system. 

Editor's note:
Opinion pieces reflect the personal opinion of individual authors. They do not allow any conclusions to be drawn about a prevailing opinion in the respective editorial department. Opinion pieces might be deliberately formulated in a pronounced or even explicit tone and may contain biased arguments. They might be intended to polarise and stimulate discussion. In this, they deliberately differ from the factual articles you typically find on this platform, written to present facts and opinions in as balanced a manner as possible.

Join the conversation...

Login or register to write comments and join the discussion!
KC
Karolina Cirjak United Kingdom
on 21 February 2022, 15:44 UTC

Excellent article Ed. It does matter how Pilots are referred to, legally and practically.
0

PB
Petar Bubic Split Maritime Pilots, Croatia
on 9 May 2021, 06:32 UTC

From the legal point of view, it doesn't matter whether the pilot is called "an advisor" or "specialist".
0

Herman Broers Loodswezen Rotterdam - Rijnmond, Netherlands
on 7 May 2021, 08:54 UTC

When a company hires a consultant, that person is en expert, a specialist, and an advisor. The Company still holds the responsibility of the management since the consultant does not know all ins and outs of that company. Hiring a pilot is much alike. In my opinion, the master should be encouraged to keep on thinking for himself, just as the pilot should do in his role as advisor, expert, specialist. Together they will then form a team which brings together the best of both worlds: knowledge of the ship, local knowledge and a combined year long experience of maritime expertise. So for the question " Best performance, master or pilot?" , forget the "or", embrace the "and".
4

RC
Ricardo Caballero Vega Panama Canal Pilots Association, Panama
on 5 May 2021, 23:09 UTC

Many might not agree with me, but irrelevant of the definitions of "adviser, specialist, or expert" to fill a legal gap, in reality is pilots, being all of the above, should always have the conn of the ship. I am sure this is what actually happens in most ports and waterways.

The rol of pilots still remains underestimated by many out there. I guess, liability is a key word here.
2

A community member on 28 April 2021, 20:59 UTC

This comment has been removed.

RT
ROB TANNER Port Authority New South Wales, Australia
on 28 April 2021, 02:27 UTC

Ed has completely encompassed the understanding and identity of what marine pilots do. The description of a marine pilot as a specialist is very accurate and to the point. We are definitely much more than an adviser.
1

HO
Harun Ozdamar Anadolu Kilavuzluk A.S. - Ankas Pilot Yarimca, Turkey
on 27 April 2021, 16:54 UTC

Pilots can be called "specialist adviser" then it could meet legal definition.
1

AP
Captain Andreas Paris Cyprus
on 27 April 2021, 14:49 UTC

Fully agree
1

A community member on 27 April 2021, 07:31 UTC

This comment has been removed.

Read more...

Opinion The Story behind the Puget Sound Pilots Maternity Policy

by Writer Mauri Shuler - published on 19 September 2022

The Puget Sound Pilots have captured what other businesses have done: create a comprehensive dedicated maternity plan that can be a model for others.

3

Article Shore Based Pilotage, a matter of trust

by Ed Verbeek - published on 14 October 2021

Issues like the Covid 19 crisis and the moves towards increased autonomy appear to be driving a renewed interest in Shore Based Pilotage (SBP), nowadays often called Remote Pilotage.

4

Video A View From The Bridge with Ivana Maria Carrioni-Burnett

published on 13 May 2025

This is a Maritime Navigation Group Webinar Series brought to you by the Royal Institute of Navigation, and hosted by Maritime Pilot Ivana Maria Carrioni-Burnett. Find out more about our Maritime Navigation Group: https://rin.org.uk/page/MaritimeNavigationGroup *** Connect with us: RIN Website: https://rin.org.uk/ RIN Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/RoyalInstituteofNavigation/ RIN X: https://x.com/at_RIN RIN Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/company/royal-institute-of-navigation...

0

Article Murphy's law on pilot boarding - Arie Palmers

by Arie Palmers - published on 20 July 2021

"Anything that can go wrong will go wrong."

2

Video MISSISSIPPI RIVER - pilot onboard - helmsman on action -

published on 22 October 2021

MALACCA STRAIT FROM EAST TO WEST ▶️ https://youtube.com/shorts/UXGMa5Qs4Zo?feature=share MY NORMAL DAYS AS SEAFARER "PACIFIC OCEAN" ▶️ https://youtu.be/kkdh5qv7Jhg Crew Change at Port of Elizabeth, South Africa ▶️ https://youtu.be/l2VtIJG5PuM SANTA BARBARA Popawis🤣🥵💦 ▶️ https://youtu.be/brur6izWHpw RICHARDS BAY, SOUTH AFRICA "APPROACHING" ▶️ https://youtu.be/3zEEmPZMAKc COCA COLA, FINLAND "UNANG TIMON AB - HELMSMAN" 😎🌊⛴🏗 ▶️ https://youtu.be/GmIL1d7ljyE UNEXPECTED ROLLING TWO...

0

Video Pilot services at Point Lonsdale, Victoria, Australia.

published on 14 August 2024

A busy morning with all three pilot services on jobs at Point Lonsdale, Victoria, Australia.
Ship spotting at Point Lonsdale and other water activities.

0

Opinion Pilot ladders: Compliance by design, failure by operator

by Herman Broers - published on 10 March 2022

It is not often that this blog is used to show bad practice, however in this case some pictures tell a whole story. Ship is compliant by design for rigging a combination. How about the operator(s)?

1

Article Effects of the Chinese New Year on the global ship traffic

by Simone Moser, LuxSpace Sàrl - published on 29 January 2020

This year, the Chinese New Year holiday celebrates the year of the Rat. The Chinese New Year, also known as the Spring Festival or Lunar New Year is celebrated by more than 20% of the world’s population. More than that, it is also the longest seasonal holiday in China. Most of the population saves up its annual holidays to take a few weeks off and spend time with the family.

0

Article Argentina: Pilot died of heart attack on board

published on 3 March 2021

Pilot died of heart attack on board of tanker JC BAZAN, berthed in San Lorenzo, Argentina, Parana river, on Mar 2.

1

Video Pilots Take on Rough Seas

published on 24 March 2022

Unless you were paying attention on your last cruise, you might have missed the pilot boat bringing the pilot out to your cruise ship.

0